Celebrate the Heart of Country, Americana, and Roots Music!

Drop Us A Line, Y'all

Y'all interested in advertising, partnering up, contributing stories, joining our team, or just got a question? Well, don't be shy, drop us a line!

Follow Us

Keith Whitley Looks Back on Past Relationship with “I Wonder What You Think of Me”

Keith Whitley Looks Back on Past Relationship with “I Wonder What You Think of Me”
by
  • Riley is a Senior Country Music Journalist for Country Thang Daily, known for her engaging storytelling and insightful coverage of the genre.
  • Before joining Country Thang Daily, Riley developed her expertise at Billboard and People magazine, focusing on feature stories and music reviews.
  • Riley has a Bachelor of Arts in Journalism from Belmont University, with a minor in Cultural Studies.

We all had that high school sweetheart we will never forget. For Keith Whitley, it was so deep and serious that even after all these years, he wondered if he still lingered in her mind. 

Written by Sanger D. Shafer, country musician Keith Whitley released “I Wonder What You Think of Me” on June 1, 1989. It was the title track to his third studio album, I Wonder Do You Think of Me. The song rose to Billboard Hot Country Songs at No. 1 and spent fourteen weeks on the chart. It also topped the Canada Country Tracks that year. 

Unfortunately, the number one hit was released the month after Whitley’s death from alcohol poisoning. Hearing him ask, “Do you think of me?” was a gut-wrenching experience for his fans. But thanks to songwriter Shafer, the song joins the list of Keith Whitley’s number-one hits.

In an interview collected by Songfacts, Shafer shared on the Billboard Book Of Number One Country Hits, “When I first got married to Lyndia, she sold her house and bought me an electric piano, and that’s the first melody I came up with.”

He finished writing the song in 1986, and regardless of Whitley’s circumstances, they had already planned to release the song. “It kind of hits the nail on the head,” Shafer said. 

Meaning Behind the Song

“I Wonder What You Think of Me” was a profound and honest narrative of a man’s yearning, and Keith Whitley was able to deliver just that. The singer recalls the places and memories he shared with his high school lover. Those teenage years were some of the most romantic moments he had when he was young and in love enough to miss classes with her. Even if they had separated ways, he would still choose to go back in time with her if he could. 

RELATED: Jamey Johnson’s Soothing Rendition of “I Wonder Do You Think of Me”

When one longs for a past love, you can’t help but think of how youthful you were back then. Unfortunately, for the singer, they didn’t have closure after they both graduated from high school. He emphasized this through the lyrics, “To a fire that’s still burning; Oh, in my heart that old graduation day. You just drifted away.” He then recalls the times he rarely played football. She would think of him as her hero. The mellow rhythm of the song further intensifies a relatable sentiment many yearners can connect with; when one speaks the universal language of love and loss, people flock together to appreciate a masterpiece. 

We often hear the line, “First love never dies.” That kind of love is often irreplaceable, no matter how many years have passed. Go back in time and reminisce about your childhood love through Keith Whitley’s “I Wonder What You Think of Me.”

Latest Stories

Lukas Nelson Honors His Dad with a Heartfelt "Always On My Mind" Cover

Lukas Nelson Honors His Dad with a Heartfelt “Always On My Mind” Cover

In 2013, Lukas Nelson proved that talent truly runs in the family when he delivered a moving rendition of his father Willie Nelson’s classic hit, “Always On My Mind.” Performed ...

Alan Jackson and George Strait's "Murder on Music Row" Honors True Country

Alan Jackson and George Strait’s “Murder on Music Row” Honors True Country

When George Strait and Alan Jackson came together to perform “Murder on Music Row,” it wasn’t just another duet—it was a moment that sent ripples through country music history. These ...

Dolly Parton, Vince Gill, and Keith Urban Unite for "He Stopped Loving Her Today"

Dolly Parton, Vince Gill, and Keith Urban Unite for “He Stopped Loving Her Today”

In October 2010, the Country Music Hall of Fame became the setting for a moment of country music magic. Three legendary artists—Dolly Parton, Vince Gill, and Keith Urban—joined forces for ...

8-Year-Old Annafaith Wows with Cover of Willie Nelson's "Always on My Mind"

8-Year-Old Annafaith Wows with Cover of Willie Nelson’s “Always on My Mind”

Willie Nelson’s “Always on My Mind” is one of those rare songs that seems to transcend time, weaving its way into the hearts of listeners for decades. Covering such an ...

Garth Brooks' Daughter Allie Colleen Scores Her First Top-40 Country Hit

Garth Brooks’ Daughter Allie Colleen Scores Her First Top-40 Country Hit

In 2021, Allie Colleen, the youngest daughter of country legend Garth Brooks, proved that musical talent runs in the family. With her single “Ain’t the Only Hell (My Momma Raised),” ...

Reba McEntire and Dolly Parton's "Does He Love You" Is the Collaboration We've Been Waiting For

Reba McEntire and Dolly Parton’s “Does He Love You” Is the Collaboration We’ve Been Waiting For

When Reba McEntire and Dolly Parton team up, it feels like the stars have aligned over Nashville. These two queens of country music, with careers that have shaped the genre ...

Ben Haggard's "As Haggard as They Come" Honors His Father While Defining His Own Path

Ben Haggard’s “As Haggard as They Come” Honors His Father While Defining His Own Path

In 2019, Ben Haggard delivered a performance at the Grand Ole Opry that felt like a love letter to his roots and a bold step toward his future. His song, ...

Mo Pitney's "Borrowed Angel" Is a Love Letter to Traditional Country

Mo Pitney’s “Borrowed Angel” Is a Love Letter to Traditional Country

In a time when country-pop dominates the charts, Mo Pitney stands out as a refreshing reminder of what makes traditional country music timeless. In an episode of Country Road TV ...

Hannah Kay Honors Loretta Lynn in Powerful "Coal Miner's Daughter" Performance

Hannah Kay Honors Loretta Lynn in Powerful “Coal Miner’s Daughter” Performance

In a world where country music continually evolves, some voices remind us of its timeless roots. In 2019, then-18-year-old Texas singer Hannah Kay did just that with her moving rendition ...

Zach Top’s Journey from Farm Life in WA to Breakout Country Music Star

Zach Top’s Journey from Farm Life in WA to Breakout Country Music Star

Zach Top didn’t just stumble into country music fame; he built his way there from the ground up, starting on a modest farm in Sunnyside, Washington. Far removed from Nashville’s ...