The National Anthem can turn a singer into a legend or the internet’s favorite punching bag. Just ask Ingrid Andress.
Last summer, she took the field at the MLB Home Run Derby. She delivered what might go down as one of the most painful anthem performances in country music history. Off-key, off-rhythm, and visibly off her game, it didn’t take long for fans to speculate that something was wrong. The next day, Ingrid didn’t try to spin it—she admitted she was drunk, apologized, and checked herself into rehab.
Fast forward seven months, and Ingrid stepped up to the mic again. But this time, the big question wasn’t if she could sing—could she earn back the respect she lost.
Her Second Chance—A Step in the Right Direction
On February 28, 2025, Ingrid made her return at a Colorado Avalanche hockey game in her home state. There was no big announcement beforehand—just her, standing at center ice, ready for redemption.
And compared to last time? It was miles better. No slurring, no awkward pauses—just Ingrid singing the anthem as it was meant to be sung. Her voice still had a slight shakiness, especially on the higher notes. Still, she held it together and delivered a respectable performance.
The crowd inside Ball Arena responded with loud cheers, and many on social media saw it as a redemption moment. Walker Hayes commented, “Come on!!!!!!! So so so good.” Parson James added, “What an incredibly powerful way to move forward.”
One fan wrote on Instagram, “So glad to see this! Killing it!” Another chimed, “She deserves a second chance, and she proved she can do it sober.”
But not everyone was convinced.
For You
Not Everyone’s Ready to Move On
While some fans were happy to see her bounce back, others weren’t impressed. A few skeptics on social media claimed her voice still wasn’t strong enough, with one X user writing, “Yeah, better than last time, but still not great.” Another harshly commented, “She sounds like someone trying to prove they can sing after too many drinks at karaoke.”
Then there were the unfair jabs, with some questioning whether she was even sober—an unnecessary and low-blow take.
But the difference this time? The negativity didn’t overshadow the performance.
Why Do People Care So Much About the National Anthem?
Singing “The Star-Spangled Banner” is one of the toughest tests for any artist. It’s a song with a massive vocal range; if you mess it up, there’s nowhere to hide. Some singers rise to the occasion and create magic—others crash and burn.
Look at Chris Stapleton’s 2023 Super Bowl performance for proof of how powerful this song can be. With just his guitar and that raw, soul-stirring voice, he delivered a version so moving that NFL players had tears running down their faces. That’s what happens when an artist connects with the song and the moment.
Ingrid’s anthem wasn’t that. But it also wasn’t the disaster people expected.
What’s Next for Ingrid?
Rumors swirl that she’s been working on new music, and this performance could be the first step in reshaping her narrative. Whether country fans fully embrace her comeback remains to be seen, but one thing is clear—she didn’t let one bad night define her.
Redemption stories are a big part of country music, and Ingrid Andress is writing hers in real-time. Are people ready to turn the page with her or not? Well, that’s up to them.
